A Song of Ice and Fire by George R. R. Martin
A Song of Ice and Fire is not a book as such, but actually a series, so far consisting of four novels (“A Game of Thrones”, 1996, “A Clash of Kings”, 1999, “A Storm of Swords”, 2000, and “A Feast for Crows”, 2005) with three more planned for future release. It is the only fantasy series which has come close to matching The Lord of the Rings in creating a whole new world which is fantastic and believable at the same time. The main characters are also incredible lifelike in that there is no one who is entirely good, or entirely evil. The least likeable one may well be the most reliable one after a while, and the ones who were sensible and reasonable to begin with turn into self serving madmen. None of them are entirely safe, either. There are no main characters in A Song of Ice and Fire; any and all of them might die at any given moment.
The world feels real. We’re given glimpses of the most varying landscapes, climates, civilisations, and yet we get the impression that we have only seen a minute part of it all.
But the main thing is this: It’s got Dragons in it. It was thought that they had died out, but three hatchlings are around, and we are granted the privilege of seeing them grow up. Grown Dragons in ASOIF are apparently creatures of a size beyond anything imaginable and they are formidable foes (or allies).
Despite all those positive points, it is difficult to justify choosing A Song of Ice and Fire for my top ten list, as it seems to have hit some sort of a wall. While the first three books were published in four years, the fourth installment was 5 years in the making. This long delay was in part due to the fact that it had gotten too long, and Mr. Martin decided to make it into two books. Not going the normal route of splitting the book halfway through the story, he decided to focus on only half the characters which bascîcally meant completely rewriting the book. And although one would imagine that the whole story for the other half had been written by then, the second book, focussing on the second half of the cast, is still not published and no information as to its publishing date is forthcoming.
I find it difficult to make up my mind on where I stand on this entire issue. On the one hand I do feel that it is the author’s prerogative to write (or not write, as the case may be) as he or she pleases. They are the creators of their works. Readers’ rights are limited.
On the other hand I do understand readers who feel cheated by Mr. Martin. It is true that he seems to have time to promote his existing work in many different ways (a D&D based table top pen and paper role playing game published by Green Ronin being one of them, an upcoming video game another). He has time to be involved with HBO’s pilot to a TV series based on his books (ok, the news IS great. Sean Bean will play Ned Stark). He has time to edit tributes to Jack Vance and he has time to do a thousand other things, but the most recent update on his website concerning the next instalment of A Song of Ice and Fire is dated January 2008 (on a side note, his website is a bit of a disgrace, it seems to have been done the “write way”)
What Mr. Martin has produced so far is nothing short of brilliant. That is why I have A Song of Ice and Fire on my top ten list. What has been going on since then is actually sad and disappointing. By the time “A Dance with Dragons” will be published (if it ever is published) I will have forgotten the finer points of the plot, the minor character which make the story so rich, and I will have to re-read not one, but two 800 page novels to appreciate the new one. And to be honest, I am not sure if I’m willing to invest that much time. As a reader, I do not have the right to demand of the author to write, but I do have the right to refuse to read.